top of page

Walking wins over running!

Aug 15, 2024
2 min read

Updated: Sep 15, 2024




Walking vs. running. Photo source: https://live.staticflickr.com/3594/3358399450_d61c3ac25c_b.jpg

Decades ago many considered running, jogging and other vigorous exercises as the best way to maintain optimum level heart health. But today researchers are realizing that while every exercise has overall health benefits, too vigorous exercise can actually harm the heart.

      In two studies, researchers compared data of 33,060 runners and 15,045 walkers, aged 18 to 80, over a six-year period.

 The test was an ideal comparison of moderate-intensity vs. vigorous-intensity exercise, because running and walking both work the same muscle groups.  Scientists discovered that for the same amount of energy expended, walkers experienced greater health benefits than runners. The results, reported in the American Heart Association journal “Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis and Vascular Biology”, revealed the following:

—“Running reduced the risk of heart disease by 4.5% while walking reduced it by 9.3%.”

—Running reduced the risk of first-time high blood pressure by 4.2% while walking reduced it by 7.2%.

—“First-time high cholesterol risk was lowered by 4.3% by running and 7% by walking.

 So what other advantages does walking have over running? While running can harm the heart, walking actually improves the efficiency of the heart. Walking stimulates one of the goals of modern cardiology—it assists the vagus nerve (one of the twelve cranial nerves forming part of the involuntary nervous system) in its function of regulating the heart rate, so that the heart is not overworked.

 According to an article by Bernell E. Baldwin, Ph.D., europhysiologist, “walking outdoors in nature can also lower the adrenaline in the blood, which means less stress” hence a slower heartbeat. Baldwin stated that jogging and aerobics cause blood platelets to become inflamed because these activities spill stress hormones into the blood. The platelets then initiate clotting and deprive the blood of “a clot-dissolving enzyme called plasmin or fibrinolysin.” Baldwin also stated that competition compounds the problem.

 Conclusion: short term or intermittent running may be okay, but as a continuous exercise regimen, walking wins.



 


Comments


bottom of page